A federal appeals court has rejected a request to reconsider its decision overturning a $31.8 million jury verdict against two Curaleaf subsidiaries, leaving in place a ruling that prevents federal courts from enforcing certain marijuana contracts because the activity remains prohibited under federal law.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit denied the rehearing request on November 17, according to a report from Law360. The decision marks another setback for Michigan marijuana cultivator Hello Farms Licensing MI, which had sought to restore a multimillion-dollar judgment stemming from a breached marijuana supply agreement.
The dispute involves GR Vending MI and CURA MI, two subsidiaries of Curaleaf Holdings, which entered into an agreement in November 2020 to purchase marijuana grown by Hello Farms during its 2020 and 2021 harvests.
After accepting approximately 2,000 pounds of marijuana, GR Vending stopped taking additional deliveries as wholesale prices declined. Hello Farms subsequently sued for breach of contract, and a federal jury awarded the company $31.8 million in damages. With prejudgment interest, the judgment eventually reached approximately $37.2 million.
However, in September, a three-judge panel of the Sixth Circuit reversed the verdict, concluding that federal courts cannot enforce contracts requiring conduct prohibited under the federal Controlled Substances Act, even when the businesses involved are operating legally under state marijuana laws.
The court also rejected arguments that federal protections for state medical marijuana programs or the April 2026 rescheduling of certain medical marijuana activities to Schedule III made the agreement enforceable. The judges determined that those developments did not retroactively legalize the transactions involved in the case.
As previously reported by The Marijuana Herald, Hello Farms petitioned the Sixth Circuit on October 8 to reconsider the ruling, arguing that allowing marijuana businesses to escape contractual obligations by invoking federal prohibition could create widespread instability in regulated markets.
The National Organization for the Reform of Marijuana Laws (NORML) subsequently submitted a brief supporting reconsideration, arguing that federal marijuana prohibition should not automatically prevent state-licensed businesses from recovering damages when commercial agreements are breached.
The court’s November 17 rejection leaves the September decision intact. The ruling carries particular significance for marijuana businesses in Michigan, Ohio, Kentucky and Tennessee, the four states covered by the Sixth Circuit, where federal courts are bound by its precedent.
The decision does not prevent marijuana businesses from entering into contracts under applicable state laws, but it establishes a significant obstacle to enforcing certain agreements in federal court when performance involves activity prohibited under federal law.
Hello Farms could still petition the U.S. Supreme Court to review the case, although the justices are not required to accept it.
The case is Hello Farms Licensing MI, LLC v. GR Vending MI, LLC, No. 25-1759.
Related posts:

New York's Highest Court Takes Up Case That Could Affect Appeals of Past Marijuana Convictions

U.S. Supreme Court Gives Washington Just Four More Days in Marijuana Residency Case After State Requ...








