Study Finds Private Marijuana Retail Systems Offer Greater Product Variety and Convenience Than Government-Run Stores

A study comparing marijuana retail systems across Canada found that privately operated markets provide significantly greater product variety and consumer convenience than government-controlled systems, while offering nearly identical prices.

The research, conducted by economists at the University of Regina and published in the Journal of Cannabis Research, examined how different approaches to recreational marijuana sales affect consumer access, product selection and pricing.

Since Canada legalized recreational marijuana nationwide in 2018, provinces have adopted different retail models. Some allow private businesses to operate competing stores, while others rely on government-run retail monopolies or systems dominated by public retailers.

Researchers compared private retail markets in Alberta, Saskatchewan, Manitoba and Ontario with government-controlled markets in Quebec, Nova Scotia, New Brunswick and Prince Edward Island. The analysis used product listings and prices collected from retail websites over two days in June 2024, along with provincial licensing data.

The findings revealed that private retailers offered greater product variety across every category examined. Consumers in privately operated markets also had substantially greater access to licensed stores, with at least nearly three times as many retail locations per 10,000 residents compared with government-dominated systems.

Despite those differences, researchers found no statistically significant difference in marijuana prices between the two models.

Private retailers had an average price of $6.46 per gram, compared with $6.50 per gram in government-controlled markets. Researchers suggested that similarities in wholesale distribution, including government control over wholesale supply in some private retail markets, could help explain why prices remained comparable.

The findings indicate that product selection and convenience, rather than lower prices, may help explain why provinces that initially adopted private retail systems have generally been more successful at drawing consumers away from the illicit marijuana market.

Greater product variety gives consumers more options when purchasing legally, while a larger network of stores makes licensed products easier to access without traveling long distances.

Researchers noted that these differences could have important implications for jurisdictions developing recreational marijuana regulations, particularly those deciding whether to allow private businesses to compete or establish government-operated retail systems.

The study also adds to broader research examining how retail access influences the success of legal marijuana markets. Although the analysis provides evidence of substantial differences between retail models, it relied on a snapshot of product listings and store availability rather than tracking individual purchasing behavior over time.

The findings suggest that allowing private retailers to compete can expand legal marijuana access and product selection without necessarily increasing average consumer prices.