Federal Appeals Court Revives Lawsuit Over Bakery Denied License After Events Featuring Infused Treats

A federal appeals court has revived a lawsuit against an Illinois city that denied a bakery’s business license following events featuring “infused” treats, ruling that a lower court improperly dismissed the case without considering its constitutional claims.

In an October 26 decision, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit reversed the dismissal of a lawsuit filed by Mary Jane Sweet Spot LLC and its owner, Ashley McCoy, against the City of Blue Island. The three-judge panel determined that federal courts have jurisdiction to consider the dispute, allowing the case to return to a lower court for further proceedings.

The dispute began in 2021 when McCoy applied for a license to operate a small bakery that would host themed events. According to court records, initial inspections and paperwork reviews went well, and McCoy said she was verbally informed that her application would be approved.

However, city officials denied the license on November 12, 2021, citing events held or advertised at the business before it received authorization to operate.

One event, held October 20, featured comedians and what court documents described as “infused” treats, with attendees charged $10 for admission. McCoy reportedly told responding police officers that the gathering was a family baby shower. The business also advertised an October 31 costume party featuring infused treats, alcohol and hookah smoking, with a $30 admission charge. That event was canceled at the city’s insistence.

The court’s opinion does not specify what substances the treats contained or establish whether marijuana was involved.

City officials argued that the events were inconsistent with the small bakery described in the license application. They also cited McCoy’s conduct during the police visit and her failure to cancel advertising for the Halloween event until directed to do so.

McCoy and the company challenged the denial through an administrative hearing, but a hearing officer recommended upholding the city’s decision. Rather than pursuing an additional appeal before the Blue Island City Council, the plaintiffs filed a petition in Illinois state court.

That petition was dismissed because the plaintiffs had not exhausted their administrative remedies and had filed their request for judicial review one day late. An Illinois appellate court subsequently upheld the dismissal based on the failure to complete the administrative appeals process.

The bakery and McCoy also filed a federal lawsuit alleging violations of their constitutional rights, including due process and equal protection, along with claims involving discrimination, conspiracy and interference with business operations.

A federal district judge dismissed the lawsuit under the Rooker-Feldman doctrine, which generally prevents lower federal courts from reviewing state-court judgments.

The Seventh Circuit disagreed, concluding that the plaintiffs’ alleged injuries stemmed from Blue Island’s administrative decision to deny the business license, rather than from the state courts’ subsequent rulings.

The appeals court explained that the distinction matters because federal courts can consider certain constitutional challenges to government administrative actions even when related proceedings have already occurred in state court.

The ruling does not establish that Blue Island violated the plaintiffs’ rights or that the original license denial was improper. The appellate judges also acknowledged that a separate legal principle known as claim preclusion could potentially prevent the lawsuit from proceeding, although that question was not decided.

The case, Mary Jane Sweet Spot LLC v. City of Blue Island, No. 24-3308, now returns to the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois, where the city may raise additional defenses and the plaintiffs can pursue their claims subject to further court rulings.