New York’s highest court is scheduled to hear arguments today in a case that could determine whether people seeking relief from past marijuana convictions have the right to appeal when a judge declines to erase their conviction entirely.
The New York Court of Appeals will consider People v. Mayers, a case involving Keston Mayers, who was convicted of second-degree marijuana possession in 2017 and completed his sentence in 2019. Following New York’s legalization of recreational marijuana in 2021, Mayers sought to have his conviction vacated under a provision of the state’s legalization law.
The Marihuana Regulation and Taxation Act established a process allowing people with certain past marijuana convictions to have those convictions erased or replaced with lesser offenses under the state’s updated marijuana laws.
In Mayers’ case, a Nassau County judge vacated his original conviction but replaced it with a conviction for second-degree cannabis possession under the newer law. Although the court acknowledged that his conviction had caused severe and ongoing consequences, it determined there was no legal basis to eliminate the conviction entirely without substituting another offense.
Mayers appealed, arguing that he should have received complete relief rather than a replacement conviction. However, the Appellate Division, Second Department, dismissed his appeal in September 2025, concluding that New York law does not expressly authorize appeals from decisions made under Criminal Procedure Law Section 440.46-a.
The appellate court determined that because the Legislature did not specifically provide a right to appeal such decisions, the judiciary could not create one.
The dispute now before the Court of Appeals centers on whether those decisions can be challenged through the appellate process. It also raises questions about the authority of judges to eliminate past marijuana convictions without replacing them with lesser offenses when doing so would serve the interests of justice.
Under current New York law, certain marijuana convictions qualify for automatic expungement, while others require individuals to petition a court for relief. The distinction is particularly important for convictions involving conduct that remains illegal but carries reduced penalties under the state’s newer laws.
A ruling in Mayers’ favor on the appealability question could allow people who receive only partial relief from past marijuana convictions to seek additional review in higher courts.
The case is People v. Mayers, docket number APL-2026-00022. The Court of Appeals has not yet issued a ruling.
Related posts:

Federal Appeals Court Rejects Bid to Restore $31.8 Million Marijuana Verdict Against Curaleaf Subsid...

U.S. Supreme Court Gives Washington Just Four More Days in Marijuana Residency Case After State Requ...








